Performing Songwriter (June 2004): "This is the kind of rock record we worried they didn't make anymore. ... It somehow calls to mind the Walkmen, the Faint, Matthew Sweet and Ween at the same time. It's power pop for people who hate power pop. Look, I don't know what the hell it is. But it rocks. And you should get it" 4 Star Rating - AMG Pick All Music Guide "This is the type of infectious music that creates volume creep: the listener keeps turning it up until everyone in the house/apartment has to tune in or leave." PunkNews.com.com "This is one of my favorite pop bands right now.  With pop that doesn't stop and hooks big enought to catch a big mouth bass, and with songs that at times remind me of Weezer's Blue Record and hints of the pixies your sure to fall in love." Drowned In Sound "For those of you who would love a band who could take the best parts of Grandaddy & mash it up with Ben Kweller, these guys from New York are your wet dream!"